Dorsey v. State case brief

Dorsey v. State case brief summary
74 So.3d 521 (2011)

CASE SYNOPSIS

Defendant sought review of the decision of the Circuit Court for the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, Palm Beach County (Florida), which convicted him of two counts of second-degree murder under § 782.04, Fla. Stat. (2006), possession of a firearm by a convicted felon, and carrying a concealed firearm.

CASE FACTS
Defendant appealed his convictions for two counts of second-degree murder, possession of a firearm by a convicted felon, and carrying a concealed firearm. His charges arose from a confrontation at a high school "keg" party that ended in tragedy, the loss of two young lives.

DISCUSSION

• The appellate court affirmed the convictions for the weapons charges but found that the evidence was insufficient to sustain convictions for second-degree murder. 
• Instead, the evidence established an impulsive overreaction to an attack, which warranted convictions for manslaughter. 
• Although a jury could reasonably have found that defendant's use of a gun was excessive, thereby negating a finding of self-defense, no evidence was presented that the defendant acted out of ill will, hatred, spite, or an evil intent. 
• The trial court erred in instructing the jury on the justifiable use of deadly force, specifically regarding the duty to retreat under the Stand Your Ground law. 
• Accordingly, defendant's convictions for second-degree murder were reversed and remanded for a retrial on manslaughter charges.

CONCLUSION
The convictions for the weapons charges were affirmed, but defendant's convictions for second-degree murder were reversed and remanded for a retrial on manslaughter charges.


Recommended Supplements for Criminal Law