Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Cherokee Nation v. Georgia case brief summary

Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 30 U.S. 1 (1831)
At this point people think tribes are going to disappear and it’s cheaper to make treaties than war, has 1802 treaty w/ fed gov’t, gold is discovered, “five civilized tribes” were very successful in assimilating, but then increasing threats, demands, and state rights. Also, Marshall is dealing with threat of civil war and problems with the court re enforceability and Jackson, President.

o    Cherokee files directly with SCt on Ct’s original j’dic over suits between states and foreign nations

o    Q:  (1) Legal authority to hear the case (2) turns on “Do Cherokees constitute a foreign state in the sense of the constitution?”

o    A: The Cherokee nation is not a state, not a foreign nation, but instead a domestic dependent nation

§  Note the dicta: “they have been uniformly treated as a state from the settlement of our country”

§  “state of pupilage” . . . relation to united states resembles “a ward to his guardian”

§  Article III § 8—Indian Commerce Clause-- Empowers Congress to “regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several states and with the Indian tribes”

·         textual argument, clearly perceived not as “Foreign nations”

§  Separate foreign nations and Indian tribes are not the same

·         Tribes need protection from fed gov’t

·         Rely on fed “kindness and power”

·         Appeal to fed for relief

·         Report to president

·         3 categories: states, nations, Indian tribes

o    Powers lost: Power to freely convey their title and Power to act as a foreign nation, powers of foreign affairs

o    Thompson dissent

§  Tributary and feudatory states do not thereby cease to be sovereign and independent states, so long as self government and sovereign and independent authority is left in the administration of the state

See also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherokee_Nation_v._Georgia

No comments:

Post a Comment

Search Thousands of Case Briefs and Articles.