Sunday, December 22, 2013

Truck Insurance Exchange v. Michling case brief

Truck Insurance Exchange v. Michling case brief summary
364 S.W.2d 172 (1963)

CASE SYNOPSIS
Petitioner employer appealed a judgment from the Court of Civil Appeals from Atascosa County, Eleventh District (Texas), which affirmed the judgment of the trial court awarding death benefits provided by the Texas Workmen's Compensation Act to respondent wife and other statutory beneficiaries.

CASE FACTS
Respondents wife and other statutory beneficiaries sought to introduce the wife's testimony in an action for workmen's compensation death benefits after her husband died. Respondent wife's testimony was to the effect that her husband had told her that his head hurt him terribly and that he had hit his head on the bulldozer while at work. He died a few weeks later. The testimony was offered to prove the injury was work-related. The trial court awarded benefits to respondents, the court of appeals affirmed, and petitioner employer appealed the judgment.

DISCUSSION

  • On appeal, the court reasoned that, to come within the res gestae exception to the hearsay rule, the statement must have been made as a result of some startling occurrence which rendered the utterance spontaneous and unreflecting. 
  • The court noted that the startling occurrence itself cannot be proven by the statement alone. 
  • Respondent wife's testimony of the conversation with her husband, however, was the only evidence of the alleged work-related accident. 
  • Without independent proof of the occurrence, the court held that the statement was inadmissible. 
  • The judgment was reversed and rendered in favor of petitioner.
CONCLUSION
The judgment of the appellate court for respondent wife and other statutory beneficiaries was reversed, and judgment was rendered in favor of petitioner employer. The court found that the only evidence of the alleged work-related accident, respondent wife's statements of a conversation with her deceased husband, was inadmissible under the res gestae exception to the hearsay rule absent independent proof of the accident.


Suggested law school study materials

Shop Amazon for the best prices on Law School Course Materials.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Search Thousands of Case Briefs and Articles.