Tuesday, December 31, 2013

Romero v International Terminal case brief

Romero v International Terminal case brief summary
Supreme Court 1959

An admiralty case is not a federal jurisdiction case. Admiralty jurisdiction does not derive from section 1331.
Getting into federal court in admiralty case is not a federal question.
If you get an admiralty case is not a federal question.

  • Spanish man signed on as a member of the crew of a Spanish steamship.
  • Compania was the Spanish line that operated it.
  • Romero was injured when struck by a cable on the deck.

  • Romero filed suit in the District Court of New York.
  • The complaint claimed damages from four separate corporate defendants from NY which acted as the husbanding agent for Compania’s vessels while in the port of NY.
  • Jurisdiction of the court was invoked under the Jones Act and section 1331 re a federal question jurisdiction.
  • In a pre-trial hearing the court dismissed the complaint for lack of jurisdiction because the Act didn’t provide a right of action for an alien seaman against a foreign ship owner.
  • The claims under the general maritime law were also dismissed because the parties were not of diverse citizenship.
  • The court of appeals affirmed.
  • Contacts with the US were insufficient, but it left complete diversity of citizenship among Spanish subject Romero and three US corporations and so the action was remanded.
Suggested law school study materials

Shop Amazon for the best prices on Law School Course Materials.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Search Thousands of Case Briefs and Articles.