Saturday, December 28, 2013

Marshall v. Lockhead case brief

Marshall v. Lockhead case brief summary
245 S.W.2d 307 (1952)

CASE SYNOPSIS
Appellant, former property owner, sought review of the judgment of a trial court (Texas), which held that he should have taken nothing in his action to aside a prior judgment rendered in a former suit for the collection of delinquent taxes. He had sought to recover the title and possession of a certain lot sold and conveyed to appellee, purchaser of property, under an order of sale issued on the judgment in the prior tax suit.

CASE FACTS
The former owner contended that the judgment in the tax suit was invalid and void in so far as he was concerned because he was not served with citation, and that he did not enter any appearance in the suit. Hence he insisted that the trial court had not acquired jurisdiction over his person. On the other hand, the purchaser said the judgment was not void and was not subject to collateral attack in the case at the bar. The purchaser further contended that the former owner, by accepting the benefits accruing to him under the same, was estopped from asserting in this suit that such judgment was void or invalid. Two lots had been sold. The former owner claimed the proceeds from the court registry from one lot, then sued the purchaser in the case at the bar on the other lot.

DISCUSSION

  • In affirming the judgment of the trial court, the court held that where a personal judgment had been rendered against the former owner by a domestic court of general jurisdiction, and under the same his property has been seized and sold, he would not have been allowed to show by evidence dehors the record that the judgment was rendered without any service whatever upon him. 
  • He was estopped by accepting the proceeds.


CONCLUSION
The court affirmed the judgment of the trial court.

Suggested law school study materials

Shop Amazon for the best prices on Law School Course Materials.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Search Thousands of Case Briefs and Articles.