Wednesday, April 1, 2015
Surowitz v. Hilton Hotels Corp case brief summary
Surowitz v. Hilton Hotels Corp case brief
Posture: District Court dismissed the case, appeals affirms. Judgment reversed by SCOTUS.
Facts: Surowitz, a stockholder in Hilton, files derivative action on behalf of the corporation against officers and directors who had defrauded it of several million dollars in violation of Securities Act of 1933, Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and Delaware Corp Law. 60-page complaint in line with the language of Federal Rule 11 with a verification of the complaint stating that some of the allegations were true and she on “information and belief” thought all other allegations true.
Hilton moved to dismiss the complaint because Surowitz knew nothing about the complaint, facts of the case, or who defendants were. Her deposition stated so. District court dismissed rule as false under Rule 23 because the affidavit was a sham.
Surowitz was an uneducated seamstress relying on her sons business knowledge to make investments.
Reasoning: Rule 23(b) was not there to discourage everyone from suing, just to stop frivolous suits. Surowitz did not what was going on but her son did and investigated it. Serious fraud required investigations and it does not matter that she personally does not understand what is going on here. No evidence of any trickery from the plaintiffs, the only thing wrong is Surowitz relied on her son. Judgment reversed.
Harlan Concurrence: Thinks that her lawyer verifying the affidavit is enough to prove that suit is not frivolous.
Image Source Have you ever considered a career where each day offers a new challenge and the chance to make a real difference? Studying cr...
Class 1: Elements of Fundamental Value: Present Value, Future Value, Net Present Value: Elements of Fundamental Value (38) One year : ...
I can help you land in the top 10% of your law school class. Imagine, how your life would be different if you were in the top 10% o...
Corthell v. Summit Thread Company (1933) · Facts: Corthell is a salesman for Summit. He invents contraption that is bought b...