Omega Environmental, Inc. v. Gilbarco, Inc. case brief summary
(9th Cir. 1997)
FACTS
Gilbarco is a manufacturer of petroleum dispensing equipment used in gas stations and only 5 such manufacturers compete in the US (Gilbarco has 55% in the market, next two have 18%). Distributors sell about 2/3s of Gilbarco's equipment and the rest are sold wholesale to large retail chains. The distributors all have exclusive dealing relationships with the 5 manufacturers. Omega wants to set up a one-stop shop for equipment and buys some authorized Gilbarco distributors; Gilbarco immediately ceases supplying equipment based upon violation of the exclusive dealing arrangement.
Notable Facts
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_swzLXlSIIvSq_4CvpGt1rtKZJfCPAIkBNrI0YTiKTtb1nbO_01WLPDuK0LJpzK8WFejnKXEnHXOxS9afcwpZ3CstOD3O_xFAIMk_EzE4sYNUu2_7VYK6wEWoUZ_rv72yy-KTChw18D9w34sh6jFrF_FwUDbDhYbdZ4xdfDt_2q1YC77GthaCo9WOJTD6KQhahwBZ5R8oZrCSuAuCzUZvQq_QXruOwlE-nVv7ESnyaPh0Up-00TmBIH9i1vPSqEX-RPiXUcqx8pzJK3=s0-d)
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_t0s9FA-rj6F1fpc3dhBVTr9RLyglPs7YGk_Im_LpkxfWQD9H-5aMasQd25WhFQQHfBjvgqSfqzLUeEUuU8e6rV06eEXG_C62xhljcllmRMc4FJhEG4DkZ0_TjpzR2BHs38aLvkHSzv905GjVKgiqvzrgPitmvLneDNmQgcnzXEQN6MG_F3GfjLLEjAeZ60aBHN-QwQz-Nc-i23gdavlJvb6uDSrvtZfTytFl7vofhb44GLngwGQK9fq2X7yBpgEQzMNCraTqsgfs8=s0-d)
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_uHaiJLIBB4xrzsFY1ioVDiNZiFPJJ0ovDUDWX2JdKHFM8cIIQkndgjcRgdobTFJdPzVU8_s8-ZSBYgbMSkTa409tBoI4WR_fcayETtNUEkxkdFc4vz7R3JeOWIqaal5IVeqbgGdd2dG2v6aVdoUck73H1YFdQWH2HPLISAtecbFzLZrMEMmAG4lAdKJFE1DKQNEDwn9aDcxCixt4869tetI1lHpuFBAw1ley9dNiKYXyJo9ICice6_V51GVcZ21xYsEegLT6Q8W0jO=s0-d)
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_soMycX54EA-1YAvi9Sy323lZ6LjnxR9pA4Yism3bRSyNGdfIN6K3R-6kWiGXvQ9w-jWov-5FghQ3SRGXipgWJXLeSXl9jLIsF4j0yiGT8lGABDoq3uH4sfrn0XcdSwAtFqvAa0IFrAAdDnHOxu8GSA012gPzaTphMI0VWEg6jwABaZX2uH6hn02_QOuAJwR16UNNUyuwMqZfK8XO6s2Sb2xveNf03ll1XjEtKtY3boBL4TrIrMvVcwPwKJyHPBFAc69R1xah_L2fui=s0-d)
Shop Amazon for the best prices on Law School Course Materials
.
FACTS
Gilbarco is a manufacturer of petroleum dispensing equipment used in gas stations and only 5 such manufacturers compete in the US (Gilbarco has 55% in the market, next two have 18%). Distributors sell about 2/3s of Gilbarco's equipment and the rest are sold wholesale to large retail chains. The distributors all have exclusive dealing relationships with the 5 manufacturers. Omega wants to set up a one-stop shop for equipment and buys some authorized Gilbarco distributors; Gilbarco immediately ceases supplying equipment based upon violation of the exclusive dealing arrangement.
Notable Facts
- Lots of competition between the manufacturers (for distributors and sales), prices went down, not up, recently, and exclusive dealing contracts were limited to durations of 1 year and generally cancellable by either side with 60-day notice.
- Although Omega alleges that these have the effect of chilling entry to another manufacturer, Gilbarco shows that Schlumberger successfully entered and expanded.
- Although the Court acknowledges a theoretical 38% foreclosure, it rules that foreclosure from distributors is not identical to foreclosure from the market and that this foreclosure level is much lower than it appears.
- Omega’s evidence that exclusive dealing arrangements (not merely Gilbarco’s) actually occupied the entire field were apparently disregarded.
- Despite the incipiency language in Clayton § 3, the majority disagrees with the potential danger inflicted upon the industry.
Shop Amazon for the best prices on Law School Course Materials
No comments:
Post a Comment