Qualitex Co. v. Jacobson Products Co. case brief summary
514 U.S. 159 (1995)
CASE FACTS
Petitioner sought review of a judgment that set aside a judgment that respondent infringed on petitioner's trademark, in violation of 15 U.S.C.S. § 1114(1), premised on a holding that a trademark could not be obtained for a color alone.
DISCUSSION
CONCLUSION
The judgment setting aside a determination that respondent had infringed petitioner's trademark was reversed because petitioner was able to register a color as a trademark to the extent that it met the ordinary requirements to obtain a trademark.
Recommended Supplements and Study Aids for Property Law
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_vrvT45ZZhW5rfTzN3ev14maFQT4UfWV6WYUI9cPi_lfuNcYThgQcaBE91487G-W5iDMYRuJDhWVrbz6wVG3_Qjso1QevkJq_n2mArT2xS_4QJuNZLg7daZxkzc9sCJvfUQYKRB2L6ND3bSv1wCAH3_qhjgbbXZRDvc-CFR1JTC5U1dQSeNy3IMExhs0Lmxk2cQOI2Ybhe3IVqXT86nfLx9NwKxVxpVpRqJWq-8bR95oLTAPImPXx6nzVeBuBtSOahG1j1mFj8J2b8T=s0-d)
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_sLK4-E9_umNlp4gDV2kXMVTGtUMfdTOHC7YqT2I1dDYgMzPYmgnQGTP9yGL8CY1YQ5d07Em1a2Jun9Q7ps0bYzw9IkiyIH8B9S5EWmotqKoTyjcIX42RnCC1_ExWZ0sV-0rBuZsZkCR6ZNtFpSQHGknG4pC-Ixas5o0fwDTZ2irqwozMLhKzH2t0kdIboKnM38Bv9cMOa6sGY6UtreJOSoCdgQCsGft70UCwX8u30KkQM5nz6zpnnGj8_-kijnCx8ZJL06dtkSqic=s0-d)
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_t5XNIIYEU9SD8bIU1zEPa6TZ8OiKEbfgJnLv0Ls0LIF4OvWM8MAEdr-J5gR8phQw77HxXbLLzQNmXvXVnzcMJzwVsjApnOj4TNhiKLeKQSD37CQLKA_sq4DUCwj4q1SPsH2c5GMjdOypuSYDeW8WaGcmNATSW8Bi0ixLO9dM0vEd-HSAlnqiKtn-QkkZ3lFIHPEj2P1Mryw4jUnMV2LCi0iV6G1nqF3wgMhf1Fa_BUX5e7kYIOCq91MXoFpuBYLvzoCjHuPzEppew=s0-d)
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_sbKfLcvg9XAW2V7aVr6Dn-P0UuWLwpGPNQ-M_Y4jDRmblk_UD18wGcO1fmdnUGoY6_rgkRJlqbLPb7IiLa37UWqhZArAQ8X42plaGcvBMhMM87uZquiFD6nladJUyYp_RbFEfPa7FG0B90g89cWlzY_Z_rPztWJWCKQVWDbFjImNxg7WD5W8cWCWgOZz1qOALpQ9tvUz6iIj_xrZ-aeRxwLlZQMe-MmOIZi3CP-SYSyCnVptOZlgh9V3UvZTnyIsrIfMGvckcBmNit=s0-d)
![](https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/blogger_img_proxy/AEn0k_sDVFLOphlvVGkpxs5Q8U7YIBtxzfOHSS81oPjYGBDsY_0LOgavT-lb6i5Jb8Ke76-2W6pDRAbbBHL3-fMGcutIM6SMjg7dJkJonHshuQ7I56Vo432-HDVL2MUmL8PBJKQmw0s1OhZNzz3mFmC4-YoUnbPEOMbSLcBa5zarGzmiDoFvZ2atD6Hq9qObySkT-OF2ax4bwW0czRjbYKCXRyjHxO0s0b3Kj4u9LNNtQuzYrP8GF7TrsNrSNWKpNVUyUAqdmMnV-oHomLOm=s0-d)
514 U.S. 159 (1995)
CASE SYNOPSIS
Petitioner sought review of a judgment
from the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which
set aside a district court's judgment that respondent infringed on
petitioner's trademark, in violation of 15 U.S.C.S. § 1114(1),
premised on a holding that a trademark could not be obtained for a
color alone.CASE FACTS
Petitioner sought review of a judgment that set aside a judgment that respondent infringed on petitioner's trademark, in violation of 15 U.S.C.S. § 1114(1), premised on a holding that a trademark could not be obtained for a color alone.
DISCUSSION
- The court held that a color, to the extent it met the ordinary requirements to register a trademark, was registerable.
- The court also held a color could satisfy the part of the statutory definition of a trademark, which required a person to "use" or "intend to use" the mark to identify and distinguish his or her goods, including a unique product, from those manufactured or sold by others and to indicate the source of the goods, even if that source was unknown, 15 U.S.C.S. § 1127.
- The court held, however, that to the extent that a color was functional, the mark would have to be examined to determine if its use as a mark would permit one competitor to interfere with legitimate competition.
- Accordingly, the judgment that held petitioner could not register a color as a trademark was reversed.
CONCLUSION
The judgment setting aside a determination that respondent had infringed petitioner's trademark was reversed because petitioner was able to register a color as a trademark to the extent that it met the ordinary requirements to obtain a trademark.
Recommended Supplements and Study Aids for Property Law
No comments:
Post a Comment