561 So. 2d 347
SYNOPSIS: Criminal defendant appealed from a final judgment of the Circuit Court of Dade County (Florida), which convicted and sentenced him for vehicular homicide.
-Defendant was involved in a drag race.
-The other participant died after he was thrown from his car when it crashed into a guardrail. Defendant was charged with the crime of vehicular homicide.
-After the trial court denied defendant's motion to dismiss, he pleaded nolo contendere and reserved for appeal the denial of his motion.
-Subsequently, the trial court convicted and sentenced him for vehicular homicide.
On appeal, the court held that defendant did operate his motor vehicle in a reckless manner likely to cause the death of, or great bodily harm to another. However, the court further held that defendant's participation in the drag race was not a proximate cause of the deceased death.
-The court stated that the deceased killed himself by his own reckless driving.
-Therefore, the held that defendant could not be held criminally responsible for the deceased's death. -Judgment was reversed and remanded with directions to grant defendant's motion to dismiss.
-The "proximate cause" element of vehicular homicide in Florida embraces more than the "but for" causation-in-fact test as modified by the "substantial factor" exception.
-Even where a defendant's conduct is a cause-in-fact of a prohibited result, as where a defendant's reckless operation of a motor vehicle is a cause-in-fact of the death of a human being, Florida and other courts throughout the country have for good reason declined to impose criminal liability (1) where the prohibited result of the defendant's conduct is beyond the scope of any fair assessment of the danger created by the defendant's conduct, or (b) where it would otherwise be unjust, based on fairness and policy considerations, to hold the defendant criminally responsible for the prohibited result.
OUTCOME: The trial court's judgment that convicted and sentenced defendant for vehicular homicide was reversed and remanded because defendant's participation in a drag race was not a proximate cause of the other participant's death.
Interested in learning how to get the top grades in your law school classes? Want to learn how to study smarter than your competition? Interested in transferring to a high ranked school?