American Airlines v. Ulen case brief

_______
Case Summary for American Airlines v. Ulen,
186 F.2d 529 (D.C. Cir. 1949).
_______

Facts: Violet Ulen (Plaintiff) was injured in a plane crash while traveling on an American Airlines (D) aircraft.
-Violet sued for personal injuries and her husband sued for medical expenses and loss of consortium.
-American Airlines admitted to the facts as alleged by the plaintiff but denied that it or its agents had been negligent in planning and approving the flight or in the operation of the plane.
-The Defendant answered interrogatories which revealed that the flight plan had violated Civil Air Regulation 61.7401.
-The Plaintiff filed motions for summary judgment based on the answers to interrogatories.
-The judge granted summary judgment in favor of Ulen (Plaintiff) and in a trial as to the issue of damages the plaintiffs were awarded a total of $27,500.
-American Airlines appealed the ruling.

Issue: Are the parties’ pleadings the controlling factors in determining whether genuine issues of material fact remain for resolution by the finder of fact?

Holding: No. The parties’ pleadings are not the controlling factors in determining whether genuine issues of material fact remain for resolution by the finder of fact.


Conclusion: 
-The court held that the pleadings by themselves did raise genuine issues of material fact that could only have been resolved through a trial on the merits.
-However, the interrogatories showed clearly that the D had been negligent in planning the flight and thus summary judgment was appropriate.
-Affirmed – judgment for the plaintiff.


---
Interested in learning how to get the top grades in your law school classes? Want to learn how to study smarter than your competition? Interested in transferring to a high ranked school?