Wednesday, December 25, 2013

Homer v. Shaw case brief

Homer v. Shaw case brief summary
98 N.E. 697 (Mass. 1912)

CASE SYNOPSIS
Plaintiff assignor filed exceptions to the court's findings in a contract dispute, which held that defendant assignee's liability upon acceptance of an assignment depended upon the assignor's performance of his contract to transport, erect and paint the steel work required for a section of a subway which the assignee was building in accordance with the plans and specifications of the transit commissioners.

DISCUSSION

  • The court found that if not fully performed the entire contract price although payable in monthly installments never became due, or if before completion the assignor by reason of his inability to go on, voluntarily abandoned the work, he could not recover for work and labor already performed and furnished. 
  • It consequently was a question of fact upon all the evidence for the presiding judge before whom the case was tried without a jury, to decide, whether upon facing the exigencies of changed conditions the parties mutually agreed to a cancellation, and thereupon in good faith an independent contract was substituted, by the terms of which the assignee undertook to furnish sufficient funds to pay the workmen the wages then due, and their future wages as they accrued, while the assignor was to receive a weekly salary for his personal services of supervision. 
  • The refusal to comply with the assignor's requests for findings, and the general finding for the assignee manifestly showed his conclusion to have been, that the first contract was treated as having been rescinded, and the assignor had no enforceable claim against the assignee under the assignment.
CONCLUSION
The assignor's requests for rulings in so far as they were not given were rightly refused, and the exceptions were overruled.

Suggested law school study materials

Shop Amazon for the best prices on Law School Course Materials.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Search Thousands of Case Briefs and Articles.